ETUC protesters, Brussels February 2010 |
How should the economic crisis in Europe be addressed? The classical or conservative road is taken by German prime minister Merkel. She insists on a rigorous governmental
financial policy with a strict budget control. The budget should not have a
deficit bigger than 3%. Government debt should be limited to 60% of the GNP.
These strict rules are signed by all EU Governments and laid down in EU
legislation. Until now this policy has been fully supported by the Frech
president Sakozy and countries like the Netherlands, Finland and Austria.
Ireland, Portugal, Spain and Italy are working on it.
But there are also many opponents of this
policy, mainly trade unions and leftist political parties. They believe that
such a strict budget control destroys the economy resulting in massive
unemployment and poverty. The European Trade Union Confederation repeatedly has
stressed this point of view. The French socialist and presidential candidate
Hollande supports this position of ETUC (the second round between the actual
president Sarkozy and Hollande will be on May 6). If Hollande will be elected
tensions on future European policy will increase again.
In the meantime the European Commission
responded to this criticism with
the publication of a report called “Towards a job-rich recovery”. The report
says that “Job creation
is one of the EU’s most pressing concerns as it struggles to emerge from the
economic crisis. Unemployment has risen to record highs – about 24.5 million people are
unemployed,
over 10% of the workforce.”
ETUC protesters, Brussels February 2012 |
The
recommendations aim to provide jobseekers with more training and more job
opportunities. Those in work would get help acquiring the skills they need to
stay up-to-date with changing job requirements. Employers creating new jobs
would also receive support. General recommendations include:
- 1. Encouraging job creation
through support for businesses, entrepreneurs and self-employed persons,
including decent and sustainable wages.
- 2. Targeting key industries where
jobs are being generated: the green economy, health and social care sector,
digital economy, etc.
- 3. Using existing EU programmes
to fund job creation.
- 4. Reforming labour markets to
meet future demand
- 5. Developing programmes to
encourage lifelong learning and providing young people with training to advance
their careers.
- 6. Investing in skills training,
anticipating future job requirements removing obstacles to finding a job in
another EU country.
- 7. Fine-tuning schemes –
including the EURES jobs database – that match jobseekers with
jobs across Europe.
- 8. Improving coordination of
employment policies across Europe.
- 9. Increasing the involvement of
employers' and workers' groups in employment policy making.
However, the ETUC stays very sceptical on these proposals as we can read in the press release of April 18. “The Commission’s proposals will do nothing to help create quality jobs, if the European Union and its member states continue to implement rigid fiscal austerity rules. On the contrary, cutting deficits in the midst of a recession will produce a deeper recession and even higher unemployment rates. Labour market policies cannot compensate for failing macro-economic policies. “
The ETUC believes even less in the proposals for labor market reforms like for example “flexicurity” : “Whilst the model has worked in some Nordic countries, in other parts of Europe it has resulted in increased insecurity for workers.” The ETUC asks for more positive proposals: “strengthening the involvement of social partners in the elaboration of macroeconomic and labour market policy, the role of decent wages in securing job quality and domestic demand, increasing minimum wages to help prevent growing in-work poverty, action to support youth employment and to tackle undeclared work. To replace the ‘governance of austerity’ with the ‘governance of growth and good jobs’, the ETUC urges all European policy makers to advance on these proposals.”